Residency · Residency · Emergency Medicine
The Difficult Airway: Prediction, Planning, and Rescue
Defining the Difficult Airway
Terminology
A difficult airway is any clinical situation where a trained provider experiences difficulty with mask ventilation, laryngoscopy, intubation, or surgical airway access. A failed airway is defined as three failed intubation attempts or the inability to maintain oxygenation (SpO2 below 90 percent) during airway management. The most feared scenario is "can't intubate, can't oxygenate" (CICO), which mandates immediate surgical airway access.
Incidence
Difficult intubation occurs in 1 to 4 percent of operating room intubations but in up to 10 to 20 percent of ED intubations. The higher rate in the ED reflects the challenges of patients who are not fasted, cannot be optimally positioned, are hemodynamically unstable, and cannot wait for a controlled approach. The CICO scenario occurs in approximately 0.5 to 1 per 1,000 ED intubations — rare, but catastrophic when it happens.
Prediction of the Difficult Airway
LEMON Mnemonic
The LEMON assessment provides a systematic framework. Look externally for facial trauma, obesity, short neck, large tongue, or micrognathia. Evaluate the 3-3-2 rule: three fingers of mouth opening, three fingers of hyomental distance, and two fingers of thyromental distance. Assess the Mallampati score, where Class III-IV is associated with a difficult view. Check for Obstruction — supraglottic mass, epiglottitis, angioedema, or expanding hematoma. Evaluate Neck mobility, which may be limited by cervical spine immobilization, rheumatoid arthritis, or ankylosing spondylitis.
Limitations of Prediction Tools
No single assessment tool has adequate sensitivity or specificity to reliably predict all difficult airways. Mallampati alone has a sensitivity of only 35 to 65 percent. The best approach combines a composite assessment with clinical gestalt, and a backup plan should always be in place regardless of predicted difficulty.
MOANS (Difficult Bag-Mask Ventilation)
Factors predicting difficult bag-mask ventilation include a poor Mask seal (beard, facial trauma), Obesity or obstruction, Age greater than 55, No teeth (edentulous patients), and Stiffness of the lungs (asthma, COPD, pulmonary fibrosis).
SHORT (Difficult Surgical Airway)
Factors predicting a difficult surgical airway include Surgery or scarring on the neck, Hematoma or infection, Obesity, Radiation distortion, and Tumor.
| Mnemonic | Predicts | Components |
|---|---|---|
| LEMON | Difficult intubation | Look externally, Evaluate 3-3-2, Mallampati, Obstruction, Neck mobility |
| MOANS | Difficult BVM | Mask seal, Obesity/obstruction, Age > 55, No teeth, Stiffness (lungs) |
| SHORT | Difficult surgical airway | Surgery/scarring, Hematoma/infection, Obesity, Radiation, Tumor |
First-Attempt Success Strategies
Patient Positioning
Ramped or head-elevated positioning, with the ear aligned at the level of the sternal notch (the sniffing position equivalent), improves the glottic view. Obese patients benefit significantly from 25-degree head-up positioning and tragus-to-sternum alignment. The flat supine position should be avoided for intubation whenever possible.
Preoxygenation
The goal is to denitrogenate the functional residual capacity to extend safe apnea time. Standard practice is 3 to 5 minutes of tidal breathing on 100 percent FiO2 via a non-rebreather mask or BVM with flush-rate oxygen. Flush-rate oxygen at 40 to 70 L/min through a non-rebreather significantly improves pre-oxygenation. When time is limited, eight vital capacity breaths in 60 seconds is an alternative. Obese and pregnant patients desaturate much faster, with safe apnea time potentially under three minutes. Non-invasive ventilation (BiPAP/CPAP) for pre-oxygenation in hypoxic patients improves SpO2 before induction.
Apneic Oxygenation
Applying a nasal cannula at 15 L/min or high-flow nasal cannula at 40 to 70 L/min during laryngoscopy extends safe apnea time through aventilatory mass flow of oxygen. The FELLOW and ENDAO trials showed mixed results, but the physiologic rationale is sound. Given its low cost and minimal risk, apneic oxygenation should be standard practice.
Video Laryngoscopy vs. Direct Laryngoscopy
Video Laryngoscopy (VL) Advantages
Video laryngoscopy provides improved glottic visualization compared to direct laryngoscopy, with higher first-pass success in many studies — particularly for difficult airways. It allows shared visualization for teaching and team awareness. Multiple blade geometries are available: standard Macintosh-like blades and hyperangulated blades.
The Controversy: VL as Default
Several large randomized controlled trials, including the DEVICE trial, support VL for first-attempt success. Hyperangulated blades improve the view but can make tube delivery more difficult, requiring a preshaped stylet. Standard geometry VL blades allow the operator to transition between direct and video technique. A legitimate concern is that over-reliance on VL may lead to skill atrophy in direct laryngoscopy, which remains essential when VL fails or screens are obscured by blood or secretions. The current trend favors VL as the primary device while maintaining DL proficiency.
Bougie-First Intubation
The bougie (tracheal introducer) is passed under visualization, and the endotracheal tube is then railroaded over it. The BEAM trial demonstrated higher first-pass success with bougie compared to a styletted ETT in ED patients, particularly when the view is limited (Cormack-Lehane grade II-III). Tracheal clicks and the hold-up sign confirm tracheal placement. The coude tip should be oriented anteriorly.
Failed Airway Algorithm
Recognition Triggers
A failed airway should be declared after three failed attempts by an experienced provider or when SpO2 drops below 90 percent without the ability to maintain oxygenation. Recognizing a progressive "can't intubate" scenario early is essential.
Rescue Oxygenation
When intubation fails, rescue oxygenation begins with bag-mask ventilation using a two-person technique with oral and nasal airway adjuncts. Supraglottic airway devices (SGA) such as the i-gel, LMA, or King LT should be placed. An SGA can serve as a definitive temporizing measure or as a conduit for intubation. Repositioning, suctioning, and optimizing conditions should occur before any subsequent attempt.
CICO: Front-of-Neck Access (FONA)
Surgical Cricothyrotomy
When the situation becomes can't intubate, can't oxygenate, surgical cricothyrotomy is a time-critical, life-saving intervention. The cricothyroid membrane is identified by palpating the thyroid cartilage notch and sliding caudally. The scalpel-bougie-tube technique is the preferred approach: a vertical skin incision is made, followed by a horizontal stab through the cricothyroid membrane, insertion of a bougie, and railroad of a 6.0 cuffed ETT over it. This method is favored over Seldinger-based kits, which have higher failure rates. Ultrasound can be used to pre-identify the cricothyroid membrane in anticipated difficult airways. Because this procedure is rare and high-stakes, practice on cadaveric or simulation models is essential.
Needle Cricothyrotomy
Needle cricothyrotomy is a temporizing measure only, except in children under 8 to 12 years where surgical cricothyrotomy is relatively contraindicated. A 14-gauge angiocatheter is placed through the cricothyroid membrane and connected to jet ventilation or BVM with an adaptor. The risks of barotrauma, inadequate ventilation, and subcutaneous emphysema are significant.
Special Difficult Airway Scenarios
Angioedema
Angioedema can progress rapidly to complete airway obstruction. Preparation for a surgical airway should begin early. If time permits, awake intubation with ketamine sedation can be attempted. Medical treatment includes nebulized epinephrine, IV dexamethasone, and for hereditary angioedema specifically: icatibant, C1-inhibitor concentrate, or fresh frozen plasma.
Massive Hematemesis or Hemorrhage
The suction-assisted laryngoscopy and airway decontamination (SALAD) technique uses large-bore rigid suction (such as the DuCanto catheter) continuously during laryngoscopy to manage a blood-filled airway. Head-down (Trendelenburg) positioning can help prevent aspiration. Two suction setups should be at the bedside.
Obesity
Ramped positioning is critical in obese patients. Pre-oxygenation with non-invasive ventilation helps compensate for the shorter safe apnea time. Video laryngoscopy is preferred. SGA placement may be difficult, and the team should be prepared for surgical airway access.
Pediatric Airway
Pediatric anatomic differences include a larger tongue, a more anterior and cephalad larynx, a shorter trachea, and an omega-shaped epiglottis. Cuffed tubes are now acceptable at all ages with appropriate sizing. The Broselow tape guides blade and ETT size selection. Atropine premedication for infants helps prevent bradycardia during laryngoscopy.



Clinical Pearls
Always have a predetermined plan A, B, and C before any ED intubation — the time to plan is before induction, not after failure. The most important difficult airway tool is recognizing difficulty before it becomes a crisis. Apneic oxygenation with high-flow nasal cannula is a low-cost, low-risk adjunct that should be routine. The bougie-first technique improves first-pass success and should be the default in ED intubations, especially with suboptimal views. In CICO, the scalpel-bougie-tube technique is faster and more reliable than needle-based kits — train with it regularly. Never make more than three intubation attempts without reassessing the plan, as each attempt causes edema that worsens subsequent attempts. Video laryngoscopy improves first-pass success, but direct laryngoscopy skills must be maintained as a backup. The cricothyroid membrane should be identified before every intubation so that front-of-neck access is not delayed if needed. The biggest killer in the difficult airway is delay in decision-making — declare CICO early and act decisively.
References
- Driver BE, et al. BEAM Trial: Bougie use in first-attempt emergency airway management. NEJM. 2018;380:2076-2078.
- Frerk C, et al. Difficult Airway Society 2015 guidelines for management of unanticipated difficult intubation in adults. BJA. 2015;115:827-848.
- Mosier JM, et al. The physiologically difficult airway. West J Emerg Med. 2015;16:1109-1117.
- Sakles JC, et al. First-pass success without adverse events is the gold standard of airway management. Acad Emerg Med. 2020;27:637-640.
- Law JA, et al. Canadian Airway Focus Group updated consensus-based recommendations for management of the difficult airway. Can J Anaesth. 2021;68:293-363.
