Premed · Premed · Introductory Sociology
Lecture 8: Deviance, Crime, and Social Control
Introductory Sociology
Learning Objectives
By the end of this lecture, students will be able to:
- Define deviance and explain why it is socially constructed
- Describe the major sociological theories of deviance
- Distinguish between different types of crime and explain patterns in criminal behavior
- Explain the mechanisms of social control (formal and informal)
- Analyze the criminal justice system from sociological perspectives
Lecture Content
I. What Is Deviance?
Deviance is behavior that violates the norms of a particular society or group. Crucially, deviance is socially constructed: what counts as deviant varies across cultures, time periods, and social contexts. No behavior is inherently deviant; it becomes deviant when labeled as such by society. Marijuana use, for example, is deviant in some societies and legal in others. Deviance is relative to time (homosexuality was classified as a mental illness until 1973 in the DSM), place (alcohol consumption is legal in most Western countries but prohibited in some Islamic nations), social context (nudity is deviant in a classroom but normal in a locker room), and who commits the act (a police officer carrying a gun versus a civilian carrying one illegally). Deviance can be positive, as when innovation challenges unjust norms, or negative, as when it involves harmful behavior.
Stigma, a concept developed by Erving Goffman, is a powerful negative social label that radically changes a person's social identity and self-concept. Stigma takes three forms: physical stigma, character stigma, and group identity stigma.
II. Theoretical Perspectives on Deviance
From the structural functionalist perspective, Emile Durkheim argued that deviance is normal and even functional for society. It affirms cultural values and norms by defining what is unacceptable, clarifies moral boundaries, promotes social unity as people bond against deviants, and encourages social change since today's deviance may become tomorrow's norm. Robert K. Merton's strain theory proposes that deviance results from a disconnect between culturally valued goals and the legitimate means to achieve them. Merton identified five modes of adaptation: conformity (accepting both goals and means, the most common response), innovation (accepting goals but rejecting legitimate means, as in theft to achieve wealth), ritualism (abandoning goals while rigidly following means, as in bureaucratic rule-following), retreatism (rejecting both goals and means, as in substance abuse or withdrawal), and rebellion (rejecting existing goals and means while substituting new ones, as in political revolution).
Conflict theory holds that deviance is defined by those in power to serve their interests. Laws reflect the values and interests of the powerful, not society as a whole, and the criminal justice system disproportionately targets the poor and minorities. Edwin Sutherland's concept of white-collar crime -- crimes committed by people of high social status in the course of their occupations -- reveals that such crime often causes more economic harm than street crime yet is punished less severely. Corporate crime, including environmental pollution, fraud, and safety violations, follows a similar pattern.
Symbolic interactionism offers several important theories of deviance. Edwin Sutherland's differential association theory proposes that deviance is learned through interaction with others; people learn techniques, motives, and rationalizations for deviant behavior from their social groups. Howard Becker's labeling theory argues that deviance is not a quality of the act but a consequence of the application of rules and sanctions. Primary deviance is an initial act of rule-breaking that may go unnoticed, while secondary deviance results from being labeled as deviant, at which point the label becomes a master status. The deviant career describes the process by which a person increasingly identifies with and commits to a deviant role. Sykes and Matza identified techniques of neutralization -- rationalizations that deviants use to justify their behavior, including denial of responsibility, denial of injury, denial of the victim, condemnation of the condemners, and appeal to higher loyalties.

III. Crime
Crime is deviance that is formally codified in law and subject to official sanctions. It encompasses several categories. Violent crime (crimes against persons) includes murder, assault, robbery, and sexual assault. Property crime includes burglary, larceny-theft, motor vehicle theft, and arson. White-collar crime includes fraud, embezzlement, insider trading, and tax evasion. Corporate crime involves environmental violations, false advertising, and workplace safety violations. Organized crime consists of ongoing criminal enterprises such as drug trafficking and racketeering. Victimless crimes (public order crimes) involve behavior that is illegal but involves consenting adults, such as drug use, prostitution, and gambling, though whether these are truly "victimless" is debated. Cybercrime consists of crimes committed using computers and the internet.
Crime statistics come from several sources: the Uniform Crime Report (UCR), compiled by the FBI from police reports; the National Crime Victimization Survey (NCVS), a survey of households about crime experiences; and self-report surveys, in which individuals report their own criminal behavior. The dark figure of crime refers to crimes that go unreported or undetected.
IV. Social Patterns of Crime
Crime is not randomly distributed across the population. By age, crime peaks in late adolescence and early adulthood and declines with age. By gender, males commit significantly more crime than females, especially violent crime, though the gender gap has been narrowing slightly over time. By race and ethnicity, racial minorities are overrepresented in arrest and incarceration statistics, reflecting both differential involvement and differential treatment by the criminal justice system. Structural factors such as poverty, segregation, and limited opportunities play a significant role, as do racial profiling and bias in policing, prosecution, and sentencing. By social class, street crime is concentrated in lower-income areas, but white-collar crime is committed by the affluent; the criminal justice system focuses disproportionately on street crime.
V. Social Control
Social control encompasses the mechanisms a society uses to promote conformity and discourage deviance. Informal social control involves casual enforcement of norms through reactions such as disapproval, ridicule, gossip, and exclusion. It is most effective in primary groups and small communities and operates through socialization and internalization of norms. Formal social control involves enforcement of norms through official institutions, including the criminal justice system (police, courts, and corrections), regulatory agencies, and professional licensing boards.
The criminal justice system operates through police (who serve as gatekeepers and exercise significant discretion), courts (which determine guilt or innocence and impose sentences), and corrections (prisons, jails, probation, and parole). Sociological perspectives on punishment include retribution (punishment as deserved consequence for wrongdoing), deterrence (punishment to discourage future crime, both general and specific), rehabilitation (reforming offenders to become law-abiding members of society), and societal protection or incapacitation (removing dangerous individuals from society).
Mass incarceration in the United States is a major sociological concern. The U.S. has the highest incarceration rate in the world, disproportionately affecting Black and Latino men. Mass incarceration has been driven by the War on Drugs, mandatory minimum sentences, and three-strikes laws. Its consequences include family disruption, community destabilization, enormous economic costs, and high recidivism rates.

VI. Deviance and Medicine
The medicalization of deviance involves redefining deviant behavior as a medical condition. Alcoholism as a disease, ADHD, obesity, and gender dysphoria are all examples of conditions that have been medicalized. This process has both benefits -- reducing stigma, providing treatment options, and framing issues as health problems -- and concerns, including the expansion of social control through medicine, the broadening of diagnostic categories, and the influence of the pharmaceutical industry. For pre-medical students, understanding how the boundary between "sick" and "deviant" is socially negotiated is essential for thoughtful clinical practice.
